An Unfair Remedy -- To What Should Not Be A Problem

Harvard University, the most famous and selective institution of higher learning in the most powerful nation on the planet, had a golden opportunity for a teachable moment. And blew it.

One of the many amazing perks of going to Harvard are faculty deans:

Faculty Deans
Each Harvard House is under the leadership of Faculty Deans, living in residence. Among varied duties of the Faculty Deans, the role of academic officer in the residential college system is preeminent. In addition, Faculty Deans are responsible for all House staff, tutorial and Senior Common Room appointments. In short, Faculty Deans set the tone for the House in its activities and in its function as a close-knit community within the context of a larger college and university.

Recently, one such dean Ronald S. Sullivan, Jr. was forced out because he was representing Harvey Weinstein who is accused of rape. You can catch up on the details here. If you havn't already heard of the professor, I invite you to look at his Wiki entry. This is not some junior faculty member paying his dues by living in a dorm.

The thesis seems to be that by representing a man accused of rape, this is support of something called "rape culture", as if anyone thinks rape is okay.

Remedy H. Ryan:

“I guess a lot of people told us at the beginning of the semester that this couldn’t be done, and that Ron Sullivan had too much power and was too good at using it,” Ryan said. “This is kind of proof that collective organizing against rape culture can do a lot.”

1. The first point that should be made is that Mr. Weinstein, has not been convicted yet and should be presumed innocent until then.

2. Even guilty people have a right to legal representation.

3. A lawyer who represents guilty people is not guilty of anything by doing so--it is literally their job.

These are lessons that any adult member of a liberal democracy should already have a handle on, that this is lost on students so elite that they can get in to Harvard is troubling.

Someday Remedy H. Ryan will be in charge of something involving other people. Maybe one of them will want her fired because she will not be fair. They will have a much better argument against her than she has against Sullivan.